Checkout Testing
Nov 25, 2025
How Do I Reduce Checkout Abandonment?
Testing different checkout content is often the fastest path to better conversion.
So, you have tried the usual fixes, but you still have a high checkout abandonment rate?
You wish you could measure precisely the impact of each element?
We have good news for you: it is now possible with Intelligems.
Because the only way to know what works for YOUR customers is to test it.
Instead of just editing your Shopify Checkout and praying that it works, you can run content A/B tests in your checkout. Testing different checkout content is often the fastest path to better conversion.
The real question isn't "How do I reduce checkout abandonment?" It's "What message do MY customers need to hear to complete their purchase?"
What Actually Causes Checkout Abandonment?
Technical issues are only half the story. Trust is what makes people buy.
Slow load times, complex forms, unexpected costs, poor mobile experiences.
Those are real problems.
Yet, even when checkout is fast and simple, a large percentage of your shoppers will not buy.
Because they don't trust you.
Missing trust signals, unclear policies, and unanswered objections create hesitation.
The most effective approach is to understand your "One Thing." If you've read The One Thing by Gary Keller, you know how focusing on the highest-leverage activity creates disproportionate impact.
That "One Thing" exists for your brand at checkout too.
There's usually one main reason why people buy from you. Is it your product quality? The pain points your product solves? Your unique guarantee?
You're probably leveraging it in your ads. But are you reinforcing it at checkout?
Example of a real test with Intelligems:
V1: no customization in the checkout
V2: review talking about shipping, customer service, and value prop
V3: review talking about product use cases and benefits
V4: review talking about pain points the product solves
V4 won because it matched what people saw in the ad. There was congruence from first touchpoint to last.
The winning message showed the RIGHT signal for that brand, not just more trust signals.
Context: Andy Costes from Blueway Labs shares the real test results behind the V1/V2/V3/V4 example above, including surprising findings about trust badges, the power of congruency from ad to checkout, and how geographic segmentation can dramatically improve checkout conversion rates.
Common Approaches to Checkout Abandonment
The typical approach? Optimize once, copy competitors, never test
When merchants try to reduce checkout abandonment, they typically follow one of these paths. Each sounds logical but leaves money on the table.
Technical optimization only. You tick all the best practices, and hope for the best.
Copy what big brands do. Look at how your competitors optimize their checkout, and replicate their blocks.
Add more trust signals. Figure more reassurance equals more trust. Add five badge sets, three callouts, two guarantees. Then wonder why abandonment didn't improve. At checkout, clarity matters more than quantity.
**Set it and forget it.** Build blocks when you first launch. Never revisit them. Never test alternatives. Hope they're working with no data to validate them.
Cart recovery emails. Focus on bringing back abandoned carts through emails. But you leave shoppers who were ready to buy.
These approaches don't tell you what YOUR customers respond to. They rely on assumptions, best practices, or copying instead of testing.
Why Testing Checkout Content Works
What builds trust for one brand might confuse another. Only testing reveals truth
Testing different checkout content reveals which messages actually build confidence with your specific customers.
Your North Star metric here is profit per visitor. Conversion rate alone doesn't tell the full story.
Profit per visitor = (Revenue - Costs) ÷ Total visitors
Checkout is the final gate before purchase. Every visitor who reaches checkout has already decided they want your product.
Small improvements here create massive returns.
Let's say you're running $2 million in annual revenue. Your checkout converts at 65%. You test showing pain points against showing reviews and discover the pain points message converts 3% better.
That's roughly $60,000 in additional annual profit. The test takes 15 minutes to set up and 3 weeks to run.
What Should I Test First at Checkout?
Start with your "One Thing." The main reason people buy from you
It's tempting to try everything at once. Add five different blocks, clutter your checkout, and you can't tell what's working.
Don't do that.
Start with your "One Thing." What's the primary driver for YOUR customers? If you're not sure where to start, let your data guide you to the biggest opportunities.
This should match what customers see in your ads. Test that first, not generic trust signals.
Run an existence test:
Your checkout with no customization
vs
Your checkout with one review, for example, addressing the One Thing people care about when it comes to your brand.
Andy has shared a Figma swipe file with 8 & 9 figure brands checkouts. Click Here
If you need more ideas, browse the Checkout Experiences Library
Andy also shared URL to help you get started quickly.
Context: Alex and Shane introduce the strategic framework for checkout testing: risk reduction vs. value-add. Learn the "don't distract" principle, why Shopify's checkout is already optimized for transactions, and how to add strategic nudges that reinforce your brand's value without overwhelming customers.
Common Mistakes That Keep Abandonment High
Don't add clutter, oversell, or test too short
Adding too many blocks at once. Five different messages creates noise, not trust. Start with 1-2 blocks.
Testing too short. Monday behavior differs from Friday. Week one differs from week three. Run tests 2-3 weeks minimum.
Only watching conversion rate. Focus on profit per visitor. It's the metric that actually tells you if you're making more money.
Making it about sales, not trust. Customers are already buying. They need reassurance, not another pitch.
Same message for everyone. New customers need more trust signals than returning customers. Use targeting.
Forgetting mobile matters most. Over 70% of checkout happens on mobile. Preview your blocks on mobile before launching.
Stop Guessing. Start Testing.
You'll see plenty of advice about technical fixes: faster pages, simpler forms, better mobile experiences.
These help. But there's another piece: the message you show at checkout.
The only way to know what builds trust with YOUR customers is to test it.
Your path forward:
Find your "One Thing" (the main reason customers buy from you)
Test 2-3 message variations that reinforce it
Use content testing (same location, different messages)
Track profit per visitor, not just conversion rate
Run tests for 2-3 weeks minimum, then act on the data
Don't guess what reduces checkout abandonment. Know!
Resource from Andy to the community:
Ready to discover what your customers need to hear at checkout? When you're ready to test beyond generic trust badges, let's get you testing beyond what's typical.
AB Testing
Ecommerce Strategy
AB Testing
